Knights in the Pros
Knights in Professional Baseball
| Name | Organization | Peak Level |
| Nelson Straley '67 | New York (AL) / Seattle | A |
| Dennis Haren '69 | Los Angeles (NL) | AA |
| Chris Wibberley '70 | Oakland | AA |
| Mark Pettit '71 | Baltimore | A |
| Chris Smith '75 | Montreal / San Francisco | MLB |
| Tim Pettit '75 | California | R |
| Bill Bordley '76 | San Francisco | MLB |
| Greg Moseley '78 | Kansas City | A |
| Dan Berthel '86 | Baltimore | AA |
| Eddie Fitzpatrick '92 | Philadelphia | A |
| Mike Zuanich '04 | Colorado | AA |
| Nathan Draves '17 | No. Colorado Owlz | Ind. |
Bishop Montgomery Baseball Players in the Major League Draft:
| Year | Name | Round | Team |
| 1966 | *Irl Davis '66 | 21 | California |
| 1967 | *Dan Graham | 2 | Boston |
| 1967 | *Nelson Straley | 42 | New York (AL) |
| 1969 | *Denis Haren | 40 | Los Angeles |
| 1970 | Dan Pritchett | 8 | Baltimore |
| 1971 | *Mark Pettit | 5 | Baltimore |
| 1972 | Chris Wibberley '70 | 4 | Baltimore |
| 1973 | *Tim Smith | 25 | Baltimore |
| 1974 | Chris Wibberley '70 | 21 | Oakland |
| 1975 | *Chris Smith | 30 | Baltimore |
| 1976 | *Bill Bordley | 1 | Milwaukee |
| 1978 | Chris Smith '75 | 11 | Texas |
| 1979 | Bill Bordley '76 | 1 | Cincinnati |
| 1979 | Tim Collins '75 | 24 | California |
| 1979 | *Mark Sewald '79 | 16 | Boston |
| 1982 | Greg Moseley '78 | 24 | Kansas City |
| 1983 | Mike Fay '83 | 8 | San Francisco |
| 1988 | Dan Berthel '86 | 20 | Toronto |
| 1988 | *Jon Newville | 61 | Houston |
| 1989 | Dan Berthel '86 | 16 | Baltimore |
| 1997 | Eddie Fitzpatrick '92 | 33 | Philadelphia |
| 2008 | Mike Zuanich '04 | 28 | Colorado |
* = drafted out of Bishop Montgomery
Bill Bordley '76 was the first player in BMHS history to reach the big leagues. He played for the San Francisco Giants.
Chris Smith '75 played parts of three seasons in MLB. He was the 2nd player in BMHS history to reach the big leagues.
Dan Berthel '86 played professionally in the Baltimore Orioles organization. He reached as high as AA.
Mike Zuanich '04 played for five seasons in the Colorado Rockies organization after being drafted in the 28th round of the 2008 draft.